probablymediocrerpgideas:

eldritchsandwich:

probablybadrpgideas:

Do the “One guard always tell the truth, one always lies” puzzle but add

– the guard who tries to lie but messes up and says the truth anyway.
– the guard who tells the truth but in such a smug and condescending way you kind of wanna disbelieve them out of spite
– the guard who only says things that are metaphorically true but literally false
– the guard who only says things that are literally true but metaphorically false
– the guard who lies but while making air quotes with their fingers.
and
-the standard guard who just needed the money and is getting increasingly concerned about their coworkers.

-both doors lead to the same room 
-the guards don’t actually know the right door
-one of the guards is on his break and the other one is resentfully trying to do it solo
-one of the guards is a werewolf and forgot the moon is rising in 1d6 turns
-one of the guards is new and has confused this puzzle with the Monty hall problem
-the guards are labeled for your continence
-the guards are mislabeled for your inconvenience
-the guards ignore their job to try to sell defective fizzy lifting potions from a multilevel marketing scam they fell for
-the guards HATE each other 
-one of the guards has to speak in rime to get into a fraternity and they are very bad at it 

– Another hallway/door that lets the party avoid the whole situation without consequence.
-Neither guard actually knows what a lie is, so they’re just contradicting the other one.